The Two Faces Of Facebook

I love Facebook. As a business owner, a marketing professional, and simply as a human being for keeping me connected with those I care about. But mostly, I love Facebook because it’s a great tool to reach entire communities and raise awareness of many great causes.

But like any tool, it can be damaging in the wrong hands. Turns out Facebook is a favorite spot for illegal traders of endangered wildlife species and poachers who sell animal-derived products such as rhino horns and elephant ivory tusks. “When we started investigating this, we began to expose this really dark underbelly of online markets,” says Crawford Allan, senior director of TRAFFIC, a wildlife trade monitoring network. “Some of the rarest species on Earth are being traded on Facebook.”

african rhino

This illegal trade doesn’t even need to retreat to the deep recesses of the so called “dark web,” where the scum of the earth makes money trading illegal material such as child pornography. Due to lack of enforcement, this trade happens pretty much in the open or by using simple code words—ox bone for elephant ivory, YTB for yellow-tailed black cockatoo, double engine or DE for red sand boas, four wheeler for star tortoise, striped T-shirt for tiger skin.

“It’s like a whack-a-mole game,” says Wolfgang Weber, senior director of global regulatory and policy management at eBay. “We start blocking the term ox bone, and then sellers switch to another name like fauxivory.” For this reason, he says, it will never be possible to achieve 100 percent detection and prevention online.

According to World Wildlife Fund, the illegal wildlife trade has become the fifth largest trade after narcotics, netting an estimated $10 billion per year. More than half of the wildlife populations around the world have disappeared in the past 40 years and the damage is getting out of hand thanks to the accessibility of online sites. From 1998 to 2011, demand for ivory—which now fetches about $1,000 per pound—increased by 300 percent. In 2007, 13 rhinos were poached in South Africa; in 2011, that figure spiked to more than 1,000. Rhino horn, despite being the medicinal equivalent of eating fingernails or hair, now fetches its weight in gold—about $30,000 per pound. If that business continues, rhinos will be extinct by 2020!

Allan and others have worked with sites such as eBay, Google Shopping and Etsy to control what’s possible by identifying what animal products can and cannot be posted online. EBay has had some restrictions on wildlife—including a ban on live animals—in place for more than a decade, and it recently included ivory. In 2012, Google reached out to TRAFFIC for help in developing a set of policies for what animal products should and should not be allowed on Google Shopping; those rules were put in place six months later. In 2013, Etsy followed suit, banning products made from endangered wildlife and ivory.

So is Facebook really to blam? After all, it is just a reflection of who we are as human beings, the good, the bad and the ugly. It’s unfortunate that we can’t get rid of all the bad ones by simply “unfriending” them like we do with those crazy old boyfriends.


Source: Newsweek, October 2014

Michela Belluso

Born in West Africa from Italian parents, Michela traveled the world before settling in the United States. After graduating from the University of Miami and The Miami Ad School, Michela freelanced as an art director in various cities across the nation, including Miami, Minneapolis and New York. Here she worked under creative leaders at renowned agencies such as Fallon, Crispin & Porter and Carmichael Lynch. Prior to starting Davidson Belluso, Michela was an art director at E.B. Lane Marketing Communications in Phoenix, Arizona, where she met her husband and business partner, Rob Davidson. At Davidson Belluso, Michela has been instrumental in the creative development of successful rebranding campaigns for Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport, the City of Phoenix Community and Economic Development Office, Tempe Tourism Office, Tempe Parks and Recreation and the Scottsdale Culinary Festival. Michela has served on many nonprofit boards and marketing committees, including The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society, The Arts & Business Council of Greater Phoenix, and more recently, The Arizona Pet Project (formerly Friends of Animal Care & Control) whose mission is to reduce, and one day eliminate, the euthanasia of homeless pets.